New network data show that internet connectivity has been further restricted across Sudan as of 6 June 2019, adding to mobile telecommunications infrastructure blackouts observed through Monday morning and over the weekend.
The latest outages come as new reports emerge that over a hundred sit-in participants and demonstrators have been killed by paramilitary groups in Khartoum, amid arbitrary violence and predatory attacks targeting pro-democracy demonstrators attending sit-ins to demand a civilian-led government.
Further, analysis of internet traffic shows that some networks appearing to remain nominally available have are now also been disabled, causing a near-total restriction on the flow of information in and out of Sudan for a significant portion of the population.
Report: Major new internet cuts detected across #Sudan; latest network data show severe restrictions on the flow of information across all providers #Internet_Blackout_in_Sudan #KeepItOn 📉https://t.co/Gsh70QzqJA pic.twitter.com/V4uMfNIJl1
— NetBlocks.org (@netblocks) June 6, 2019
Data show that more restrictions are now in place targeting all internet providers, affecting Sudan’s fixed-line connectivity as well as mobile access. Internet measurements show a markedly different, and more severe, mechanism of internet censorship than those during the rule of ousted president Omar al-Bashir.
While charts show nationwide IP connectivity has fallen to 80%, NetBlocks researchers have found that overall impact is more severe because the impacted 20% include major gateways for carrier-grade network (CGNAT) routes used to connect the majority of Sudan’s citizens.
The scale of the outage can also be observed indirectly from the loss of Sudan’s diurnal pattern, resembling an ECG heartbeat pattern in the visualization. The flattening line since 3 June shows that even where technical infrastructure is powered on, users are no longer able to go online.
Meanwhile, NetBlocks web probe data taken by network scans from vantage points across Sudan during the same period show latency peaks around the times of each disconnection event, sometimes called “throttling.” This slowing of connectivity appears to be associated with total disconnection incidents including that on the evening of 3 June.
Hence, the peaks with average latencies in excess of ~5s may represent either the purposeful slowing of internet access but could equally be a technical symptom of the wider blackouts. Ironically, aside from those periods of high latency, internet performance appears to have improved with round-trip times falling to ~1.8s due to the loss of users across Sudan and the commensurate drop in contention rates.
The latest analysis shows that parts of Sudan started going on 31 May, prior to the more severe and widely reported disruptions on 3 June and 5 June. Each of these disruption phases have have had a concurrent and cumulative effect.
Edge of network targeted
No clear statement has been provided about the telecommunications blackouts, which currently constitute a near-total blockade on information in and out of Sudan. Emerging reports suggest that citizens have struggled to stay informed, reach safety and monitor extrajudicial killings, gender based violence and other human rights violations allegedly perpetrated in recent days.
The new outages target the “edge” of the network rather than core infrastructure or specific websites, manifesting in to a total disconnection that cannot be circumvented by internet users. Sudan’s internet backbone remains connected and there are continued indications that some connectivity has been preserved by authorities, possibly for use by security forces or state officials.
On Wednesday 5 June, connectivity with fixed line provider Canar (Kanartel, AS33788) dropped to 40%, knocking out most subscriber connections:
The new disruptions come in addition to the ongoing blackout affecting mobile providers MTN, Mobiltel (ZAIN), parts of the national Sudan Telecom Sudatel / Sudani network, and education and research network SUDREN reported by NetBlocks on Monday.
Confirmed: Internet service partially cut in #Sudan amid new #Khartoum unrest limiting access to information at critical moments; unlike past shutdowns, only MTN and Mobitel affected #SudanUprising #KeepItOn 📉📈https://t.co/8Qio901WCR pic.twitter.com/yosrWf4bU6
— NetBlocks.org (@netblocks) June 3, 2019
Internet interference a hallmark of Sudan’s uprising
Through December to April, Sudanese ISPs disrupted social media, censored media and frequently disabled nationwide connectivity as protesters took to the streets to drive president Omar al-Bashir out of power.
Access to Twitter, Periscope, Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp were restored in Sudan on Thursday 11 April 2019 as the leader stepped down following months of intense demonstrations, as show in network measurement data collected by the NetBlocks internet observatory.
During the longest disruption, Sudan cut social media for 68 consecutive days, with Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and WhatsApp outages beginning 10 AM 21 December 2018 and lasting until February 26 2019, according to NetBlocks internet measurements.
— Internet Society (@internetsociety) June 6, 2019
Civil society and technical groups including the Internet Society have called for the restoration of connectivity in Sudan. The availability of unfiltered internet access and an end to political censorship remain essential for a successful transition to a civilian-led government.
Internet performance and service reachability are determined via NetBlocks web probe analytics measurements. Each measurement consists of latency round trip time, outage type and autonomous system number aggregated in real-time to assess service availability and latency in a given country. Network providers and locations enumerated as vantage point pairs. The root cause of a service outage may be additionally corroborated by means of traffic analysis and manual testing as detailed in the report.
NetBlocks diffscans, which map the IP address space of a country in real time, show internet connectivity levels and corresponding outages. Purposeful internet outages generally have a distinct network pattern used by NetBlocks to determine and attribute the root cause of an outage, a process known as attribution which follows detection and classification stages.
NetBlocks is a civil society group working at the intersection of digital rights, cyber-security and internet governance. Independent and non-partisan, NetBlocks strives for an open and inclusive digital future for all.